Review of the 77 questions the FAQ app answered in October, checked against HR & Payroll FAQ v3.1 and v3.2. Each answer was tested against the section and revision it quoted. 10 answers are outdated or conflicting, and 19 questions have no answer in the document.
Cottonwood Ford Constructors, Inc., HR and PayrollAnswer log Oct 1–31, 2026, 77 questionsFAQ v3.1 (through Oct 15) and v3.2 (from Oct 16)Prepared Nov 5, 2026
Summary
Conflict · 4.3 and 8.2
Two sections give different approval deadlines
Since v3.2 (Oct 16), 4.3 Approval deadline says Monday 10:00 AM, while 8.2 Payroll cutoff still says Tuesday 12:00 PM. Of 9 questions about the deadline after Oct 16, 6 were answered from 4.3 and 3 from 8.2 (HR_Payroll_FAQ_v3.2.docx, pp. 6 and 12).
Action: fix 8.2 in the next revision and follow up with the 3 foremen.
Not in FAQ · 14 questions
Drive time to M-480 is the top unanswered question
14 of the 19 questions the FAQ does not answer are about travel time to and from job sites, asked by 11 people. Chapter 5 covers per diem for overnight travel only.
Queued as F-01, a new section 2.4, waiting for HR and payroll to write the answer.
Revision 3.2 · 7 answers
7 answers from Oct 1–15 no longer apply
v3.2 changed 3.2 (overtime must be requested in advance) and 4.3 (new approval deadline). 5 overtime answers and 2 deadline answers were given from v3.1 to 6 people, who were told overtime is approved afterward and the deadline is Tuesday 12:00 PM.
The change to 2.2 affects no answers. Send the current text to the 6 people.
Answer log, document and revisions
Filter the log by status or chapter, or click a bar. Click a question to see the answer, the quote and why it was flagged. The FAQ v3.2 tab shows each section with the questions that quoted it, Revisions shows what changed in v3.2, and New questions shows the queue for the next revision.
0Questions in October
0Answered from the document
0Not answered in the FAQ
0Outdated or conflicting answers
Questions by chapter
AnsweredOutdatedConflictingNot in FAQ
Changed in v3.2Conflicts with another section
Revision history
Revision
Issued
In force
Changes
Approved by
Changes v3.1 → v3.2 and affected answers
An answer counts as affected when it came from v3.1 and quoted a section that changed in v3.2. 8.2 is unchanged but conflicts with the new text in 4.3.
The second app adds questions the FAQ does not answer to the queue (New_Questions_Queue_2026-10.xlsx, F‑01 to F‑04). F‑05 is proposed by this review. Drafts show where each entry would go in the document; HR and payroll write the answers.
Sources and method
Sources
HR_Payroll_FAQ_v3.2.docxCurrent FAQ, 8 chapters and 24 sections, in force from Oct 16, 202614 pages
HR_Payroll_FAQ_v3.1.docxPrevious revision, in force Sep 14–Oct 15, 202614 pages
FAQ_App_Answer_Log_2026-10.csvEach question with time, pseudonymized user number, role, quoted section and revision77 rows
New_Questions_Queue_2026-10.xlsxQueue from the second app with questions the FAQ does not answer4 entries
FAQ_Revision_History.xlsxRevision history with changed sections and approvers3 revisions
Method
Read the answer log for Oct 1–31: 77 questions with the section and revision each answer quoted.
Checked each quote against the text of the revision in force when the question was asked: v3.1 through Oct 15, v3.2 from Oct 16.
Compared v3.1 and v3.2 section by section. Answers that quoted a section that later changed were marked outdated.
Compared sections that overlap, including the approval deadline in 4.3 and 8.2 and overtime in 3.1 and 3.2. Contradictions were marked, along with answers that quoted the conflicting text.
Grouped questions with no match in the document by topic and matched them to the new-questions queue.
Assumptions and limitations
The FAQ app answers only with text from the FAQ document. The answer in the log is the section text of the revision in force.
User numbers in the log are pseudonymized. Head counts are by user number.
The correct deadline is assumed to be the one in 4.3 because it changed most recently. Payroll should confirm.
The review does not check whether the FAQ complies with the FLSA, Michigan law, Davis-Bacon requirements or the CBAs. It only checks answers against the document.
FAQ 6.1 says paid sick time follows the Michigan Earned Sick Time Act and, for union employees, the CBA. The Act's transition rules for employees under a CBA are more nuanced than that sentence, so HR should confirm the wording with employment counsel licensed in Michigan.
Policy HR-14 and its per diem rate table are referenced by the FAQ but were not part of this review. Answers for the new-questions queue are written by HR and payroll and are not included here.